Duration Of Action Of Remedies - Homeopathy 1v1k60

Duration of Action of Remedies - Homeopathy Forums

1 of 20

ENGAGE

PATIENTS

PROFESSIONALS

http://forums.hpathy.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=2804

SERVICES

STUDENTS

These forums have been archived. Visit

http://forum.hpathy.com to access the NEW HOMEOPATHY FORUMS Forum Home > General > General Discussion

New Posts FAQ

Search

Calendar





Duration of Action of Remedies Ads by Google

► Homeopathic Remedies ► Remedies for Eczema ► Diarrhea Remedies Hair Fall Treatment Treat your Hair Fall at root level painlessly with homeopathy www.hairloss-ht.com/Hair-Fall Dr. P. Banerji of India Over 14 Million Patients Treated World's Largest Homeopathic Centre www.Dr P Banerji.com/Homeopathy Book ing Site Choose From 1 Million Free Titles Now for Free eBooks! www.readingfanatic.com Post Reply Author

PHompath Member

Message

Share Topic

Topic Search

Topic Options

Topic: Duration of Action of Remedies Posted: 23 Feb. 05 at 19:26

This was posted to me by someone and seeking help. In materia medica, we see a list of duration of action of remedies. For my knowledge kindly provide the answers in sequence. ed: 06 Feb. 05 Location: Pakistan Online Status: Offline Posts: 64

1. Who first compiled this list? (Boerick or any other homeopath?) 2. When this list was first compiled? (Exact Date if available) 3. Was the list compiled in one day or duration of action of remedies were added one by one at different interval of time? 4. How many compilers were involved in compiling that list or only one writer took pain in compiling the whole list? 5. The duration of action of remedy of Rhus Tox was added just after the completion of Rhus Tox proving or it was added after long trial of clinical practice and experience.

25/03/2013 10:58 AM

Duration of Action of Remedies - Homeopathy Forums

2 of 20

http://forums.hpathy.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=2804

6. Who was the first homeopath that added the duration of action of remedy of Rhus tox (7 days) in remedy list? Was that the clinical homeopath who after practical experience finalized the duration of action of remedy of rhus tox or was that the Prover who first proved rhus tox as homeopathic remedy? If anybody could help him/her then I will forward the replies.

Lady Homoeopathic Doctor Computer Programmer & Network

Diplomat

Posted: 25 Feb. 05 at 18:07

Member

Quite Difficult and confusing. I have forwarded to few homeopaths. Let's wait ed: 07 Nov. 03 Location: Pakistan Online Status: Offline Posts: 768

Diplomat Homeopath

PHompath

Posted: 26 Feb. 05 at 00:27

Member

Received the following reply from Dr.MAS Originally posted by Dr. MAS

ed: 06 Feb. 05 Location: Pakistan Online Status: Offline Posts: 64

1. Who first compiled this list? (Boerick or any other homeopath?)

Duration of action of remedies is falsehood tip in homeopathy like any other homeopathic principle. But it has now become a prime importance if you use it the correct way. The vital role of duration of action of remedies cannot be ruled out. But the question is when, where and how it can be used? This is all confusing. Which remedy to follow after which remedy…..? Question like that is all bamboozling.

I also use duration of action of remedies but at the same time I also instruct my students don’t be confused with it, always take fresh case and prescribe what ever the remedy comes. Very simple rule.

Rehman Encyclopedia of relationship of remedies is the definite source for knowing duration of action of remedies. Dr. Rehman can be approached through email [email protected] for genuine enquiries only.

25/03/2013 10:58 AM

Duration of Action of Remedies - Homeopathy Forums

3 of 20

http://forums.hpathy.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=2804

The earlier name was “drug affinities”, Bogger Boenninghausen in 1846 (approx) published data in concise form.

Then it got famed from Boerick materia medica but who was the first? I don't know. After publication in Boerick, every body blindly started quoting that table. This is all cheating. Nobody ever bothered to check the exact listening. The most interesting point is, every body blindly verified that duration of each remedy is correct but in my case it was all gone wrong. 2. When this list was first compiled? (Exact Date if available) Read above. 3. Was the list compiled in one day or duration of action of remedies were added one by one at different interval of time? One doctor first compiled it but that doctor collected data from different doctors, other sources and books having cured stories and observations. My common sense says, it was added with different interval of time but in summarized form it was compiled later on.

4. How many compilers were involved in compiling that list or only one writer took pain in compiling the whole list? Only one doctor took pain in compiling the table but many doctors were involved involuntarily. These doctors noted their observations for different remedies, which were then collected by one doctor. 5. The duration of action of remedy of Rhus Tox was added just after the completion of Rhus Tox proving or it was added after long trial of clinical practice and experience. When Rhus Tox proving was done, it was noted that even after the stoppage of use of Rhus Tox (in crude form), the proving symptoms constantly appeared for seven days in healthy individual. Hence it was noted that Rhus tox has exact seven days of duration of action. Later on this was practically observed by different homeopaths during the practical application / istration of first dose of Rhus tox in the patient.

For example, say when Rhus Tox 200 was given, the patient responded very well and remained calm for few days until he reported that he is again feeling discomfort, at that stage, homeopath thought that action of the first dose of Rhus tox is completed but patient is not reported total cure hence one more dose after seven days was istrated. This type of observation in the coming days was very fruitful for homeopaths and helped them a lot in repeating the dose. One day, a patient came to my clinic, she was arthritis patient, after repertorization, I decided to give her a dose of Rhus Tox 1M for her knee complaint. I asked her to report to me after seven days. She came after nine

25/03/2013 10:58 AM

Duration of Action of Remedies - Homeopathy Forums

4 of 20

http://forums.hpathy.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=2804

days and said "Doctor sahib, I was feeling better but now pain has started again, give me some more good quality medicine, I want to recover as early as possible because I have to go to Saudia Arabia for performing UMRA.” To my observation, the remedy was working and the rule is, if remedy is working, then don't disturb the action of remedy by istrating over dose. I knew that Rhus tox was in her body and she does not need further treatment for the next follow up. Placebo was given and it was again instructed to report after four days, the patient came and said, “I have been recovered about 90 % but worried about relapse of complaint” , a dose of cm was given and then the patient never returned. This observation shows that, Rhus tox duration of action is ten to fifteen days depending upon the selection of potency strength. This observation shows that duration of action of remedies saved your case other wise you would have been spoiled the case if you don't know the duration of action of remedy.

According to Dr. Gibson-Miller, the columns of duration of action of remedies are not correct. To him; the Rhus Tox action is three to four months. So homeopathy is full of fraud like that, if you have money, you can become high standard homeopaths, if you could write some book you can call yourself scholar of homeopathy without knowing that what is the difference between remedy, medicine and drug? Believe me, everybody will quote you without actually knowing that what is right and what is wrong because homeopaths do not believe in practical observations. They supposed to follow what is written, they do not bother what they are observing. They always made mind before doing something and write observations according to their pre-planned thoughts.

This is the complete list of duration of action of remedies, which Gibbon compiled and appeared in Boerick. This is also supposed to claim the first compilation. Remedy---name---------Duration of Action of Remedies Aceticum acidum-------14-20 Aconitum napellus----Aesculus hippocastanum 30 Agaricus muscarius 40 Agnus castus 8-14 Alcohol - Aethanolum 20-30 Allium cepa 1 Aloe socotrina 30-40 Alumen long

25/03/2013 10:58 AM

Duration of Action of Remedies - Homeopathy Forums

5 of 20

http://forums.hpathy.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=2804

Alumina - Argilla 40-60 Ambra grisea 40 Ammonium carbonicum 40 Ammonium muriaticum 20-30 Anacardium orientale 30-40 Angustera vera 20-30 Antimonium crudum 40 Antimonium tartaricum 20-30 Argentum metallicum 30 Argentum nitricum 30 Arnica montana 6-10 Arsenicum album 60-90 Arum triphyllum 1-2 Asafoetida 20-40 Asarum europum 8-14 Asclepias tuberosa 40-60 Aurum metallicum 50-60 Baptisia tinctoria 6-8 Baryta carbonica 40 Belladonna 1-7 Berberis aquifolium 20-30 Bismuthum subnitricum 20-50 Borax veneta 30 Bovista 7-14 Bromum 20-30 Bryonia alba 7-21 Cactus grandifloris 7-10 Caladium seguinum 30-40

25/03/2013 10:58 AM

Duration of Action of Remedies - Homeopathy Forums

6 of 20

http://forums.hpathy.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=2804

Calcarea carbonica 60 Calcarea phosphorica 60 Camphora officinarum 1 Cannabis indica Cannabis sativa 1-10 Cantharis vesicatoria - Lytta 30-40 Capsicum annuum 7 Carbo animalis 60 Carbo vegetabilis 60 Causticum Hahnemanni 50 Chamomilla vulgaris 20-30 Chelidonium majus 7-14 Cicuta virosa 35-40 Cimicifuga racemosa 8-12 Cina - Artemsia maritima 14-20 Cinchona officinalis - China 14-21 Clematis erecta 14-20 Cobaltum nitricum 30 Cocculus indicus 30 Coffea cruda-arabica 1-7 Colchicum autumnale 14-20 Collinsonia canadensis 30 Colocynthis 1-7 Conium maculatum 30-50 Crocus sativus 8 Crotalus horridus 30 Croton tiglium 30 Cuprum metallicum 40-50

25/03/2013 10:58 AM

Duration of Action of Remedies - Homeopathy Forums

7 of 20

http://forums.hpathy.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=2804

Cyclamen europaeum 14-20 Digitalis purpurea 40-50 Dioscorea villosa 1-7 Drosera rotundifolia 20-30 Dulcamara 30 Eupatorium perfoliatum 1-7 Euphorbium officinarum 50 Euphrasia officinalis 7 Ferrum metallicum 50 Fluoricum acidum 30 or 1-7 Gelsemium sempervirens 30 Glonoinum 1 Graphites 40-50 Guaiacum officinale 40 Helleborus niger 20-30 Hepar sulphuris calcareum 40-50 Hyoscyamus niger 6-14 Hypericum perforatum 1-7 Ignatia amara 9 Iodum 30-40 Ipecacuanha 7-10 Kali bichromicum 30 Kali carbonicum 40-50 Kali iodatum 20-30 Kali nitricum 30-40 Kali sulphuricum 45 written in Kalmia latifolia 7-14 Kreosotum 15-20

25/03/2013 10:58 AM

Duration of Action of Remedies - Homeopathy Forums

8 of 20

http://forums.hpathy.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=2804

Lachesis muta 30-40 Laurocerasus 4-8 Ledum palustre 30 Lilium tigrinum 14-20 Lycopodium clavatum 40-50 Magnesia carbonica 40-50 Magnesia muriatica 40-50 Magnesia sulphurica Magnetis polus arcticus Magnetis polus australis Mancinella 30-40 Manganum aceticum 40 Marum verum teucrium Menyanthes trifoliatia 14-20 Mephitis putorius 1 Mercurius vivus 30-60 Mezereum 30-60 Millefolium 1-3 Moschus moschiferus 1 Muriaticum acidum 35 Natrum carbonicum 30 Natrum muriaticum 40-50 Nitricum acidum 40-60 Ntr-sul ? 30-40 Nux moschata 60 Nux vomica 1-7 Oleander 20-30 Opium 7

25/03/2013 10:58 AM

Duration of Action of Remedies - Homeopathy Forums

9 of 20

http://forums.hpathy.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=2804

Paris quadrifolia 2-4 Petroleum 40-50 Phosphoricum acidum 40 Phosphorus 40 Platina metallicum 35-40 Plumbum metallicum 20-30 Podophyllum peltatum 30 Psorinum 30-40 Pulsatilla nigricans 40 Ranunculus bulbosus 30-40 Ranunculus sceleratus 30-40 Rheum officinale 2-3 Rhododendron chrysanthum 35-40 Rhus toxicodendron 1-7 Ruta graveolens 30 Sabadilla officinarum 20-30 Sabina juniperus 20-30 Sambucus nigra 1 Sarsaparilla 35 Secale cornutum 20-30 Selenium 40 Senega - Polygala senega 30 Sepia officinalis 40-50 Silicea terra 40-60 Spigelia anthelmia 20-30 Spongia marina tosta 20-30 Squilla maritima- Scilla 14-20 Stannum metallicum 35

25/03/2013 10:58 AM

Duration of Action of Remedies - Homeopathy Forums

10 of 20

http://forums.hpathy.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=2804

Staphysagria 20-30 Stramonium Strontium carbonicum 40 Sulphur 40-60 Sulphuricum acidum 30-40 Taraxacum officinale 14-21 Tellurium 30-40 Teucrium marum verum 14-21 Theridion curassavicum 30 Thuja occidentalis 60 Valeriana officinalis 8-10 Veratrum album 20-30 Verbascum thapsus 8-10 Viola odorata >2-4 Viola tricolor 8-14 Zincum metallicum 30-40

Boerick says, duration of action of remedies of Ars Alb is above 60-90 days, see above, but B-hausen said, it is upto 36 days and to my observation, in 30C it only remain in action four days and rarely for fifteen days in high potency in acutes. Dull homeopathy. L

The materia medica pura says, “The duration of the action of large doses of rhus extends over six weeks, that of small doses is less proportionally to the smallness of the dose. On of this long duration of action the preliminary homoeopathic aggravation of symptoms is also of longer duration than with most other vegetable drugs; so that in the employment of even the smallest doses we often do not observe the amelioration until after the lapse of twenty-four hours after taking the medicine. Hence, as with every other medicine, so especially in the selection of this one, the homoeopathic rule must be strictly followed. The injurious effects of an erroneous selection are often removable by bryonia, sometimes by sulphur, at other times by camphor or raw coffee, according to the untoward symptoms produced.”

25/03/2013 10:58 AM

Duration of Action of Remedies - Homeopathy Forums

11 of 20

http://forums.hpathy.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=2804

6. Who was the first homeopath that added the duration of action of remedy of Rhus tox (7 days) in remedy list? Was that the clinical homeopath who after practical experience finalized the duration of action of remedy of rhus tox or was that the Prover who first proved rhus tox as homeopathic remedy? It was first the prover who proved Rhus Tox and then the follower homeopaths who verified the data from their clinical observations.

Dr. MAS www.drmas.tk

Email: [email protected]

My dear Dr. Mas Thank you very much for your query. I am enclosing herewith complete relationships of Mercurius. Some additions have been made very recently but I could not go through them, so you may find some typing/spelling mistakes for which I beg excuse in advance. A. Rehman

Mercurius [Solubilis and vivus] Miasm: Pso9, Syc4,8,140, SYP140. Temperament: Choler, Melan15, Phleg, Sang64. Laterality: l, r, l r, Alternating sides. Related Bowel's Nosode: Gaertner (Bach). Duration: 30-60 d. 2-3 weeks187. Remarks: It seems that when Merc fails when indicated, Merc-v acts185.

25/03/2013 10:58 AM

Duration of Action of Remedies - Homeopathy Forums

12 of 20

http://forums.hpathy.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=2804

Mercury given in form of Mercurius Sol. has toxic effects on the intestinal and oral flora up to 6X125. Should not be used lower than 12X (6C50) for danger of producing abscess in tonsils125; is toxic lower than 6X125. Don't give many doses of Merc in psoric cases, look for a deeper medicine30. In primary and secondary syphilis, Merc. is sovereign and reliable remedy, it must consequently, be continued weeks and months, during the period of pause one gives purposefully the indicated intercurrent remedy: Kali-i, Nit-ac. both in low potencies or Syph. and Sulph. in high potencies44. Hesitate about giving Merc. in dysentery unless sure it is indicated39. Sulph. intensifies its action8,16. Merc. is not followed well by Sil; Sil. does not do useful work when Merc. is still acting, or has been acting. Sil. follows well after Hep. and Hep. follows well after Merc. and thus Hep. becomes an intercurrent in that series of medicines30,56. The relationship between Merc. and inflammation should be studied very carefully. It is recommended in the later stages of inflammation when inflammation merges into suppuration, the more has pus formed, the more it is indicated ... we think of it when inflammation stage is just about over and suppuration about to set in, it works both ways, it prevents suppuration when suppuration has not taken place and hence is a remedy to be used in doubtful cases of suppuration134. As Sulph is to psora, so is Merc to syphilis and Thuj to sycosis30. Sal, Mercurius and Sulph. correspond to the three basic constitutions of Paracelsus129. All mercury preparations in albuminuria are contraindicated in lower potencies44. Merc. is seldom indicated if the tongue is dry19. Merc, Hep, Sil form trio for suppurations50. Food[s] to be avoided: Alcohol8,31, Coffee, Cold food, Hot food31, Sugar9, Wine31. Intercurrent remedies: Kali-i and Nit-ac [Primary and secondary syphilis also Sulph. and Syph44; Nit-ac also for syphilis of bones44; Nit-ac. Also intercurrent remedy in syphilitics when Merc. Fails; also also syphilis185 and

25/03/2013 10:58 AM

Duration of Action of Remedies - Homeopathy Forums

13 of 20

http://forums.hpathy.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=2804

bones44], Sulph187. Sequential remedies: Merc ? Hep ? Sulph17 Merc ? Hep ? Sil17,30,56 Complementary Remedies: Ars, Aur8,17, Bad, Bar-c [Enlargement of tonsils143], Bell [Acute rheumatism of children, besottedness, perspiration, throbbing headache, mydriasis, high fever, dreams, the child cries out while sleeping8,80], Carc50, Chin157, Hep8,17,157, Hydr [Influenza when liver is tender and torpid, the skin and sclera are yellow and there is much itching54], Iod157, Kali-i [Syphilis36,101; venereal rheumatism101; influenza, supplements the action of Merc. when the later ceases to act50], Lyc [Pneumonia with liver complications to finish the cure48; acute tonsillitis47; ulcerous or pseudomembranous inflammation of tonsils47; diphtheria47], Mez, Nit-ac [Soft chancres occurring in weakly scrofulous subjects, secondary ulcerations of mucous membranes26,96; cancer50], Phyt, Puls, Sep8,17, Sil8,50*,125 [Blephroadenitis of scrofulous persons50], Sulph8,17, Syph [In syphilitic affections47; syphilitic ulceration157; chronic cases143], Thuj. * The compiler has faithfully recorded the clinical observations of different authors with respect to complementary and inimical relationships of Merc. and Sil. Followed well by: Acon [As an intercurrent in true syphilis when there is violent inflammation of the penis following Merc101], Agar12, Ant-c, Apis, Arg-met [Cured gonorrhoea after failure of Merc25], Arg-n [Ophthalmia neonatorum when Merc. fails16,177; thick yellowish profuse bland discharge from eyes, when Merc. fails39], Ars [Fluent coryza when Merc. is not sufficient and discharge becomes more burning in character48; coryza and dysentery17; smallpox, during the progress of the secondary fever85], Asaf, Aur [Gummata syphilitica, gummatose tumors when Merc. has failed to relieve101], Bar-c [Scarlatina miliaris in scrofulous, dwarfish children33], Bell, Calc, Calc-p [Consumption10; incipient mesenteric tabes25], Calc-s [Inflammation of skin, and subcutaneous cell tissue and of connective tissue in every part or organ of the body with tendency to suppuration36], Caps [Gonorrhoea when a little, thin, gleety discharge remains48], Carb-v, Cham12, Chin, Chol [Liver diseases when (Merc. and) other remedies fail to response36; organic diseases of liver in which the commoner hepatics -Card-m, Chel, Kali-bi, Merc, Myrrr and Dipl. have failed91], Cinnb [True syphilis when no benefit has occurred from Merc10], Crot-h [Ulcers, saliva drools at night, Merc. failing39], Dulc, Echi [Suppurative appendicitis when Merc. fails54], Guaj, HEP [Otitis media when suppuration impends17; liver diseases138; post-influenzal complications with involvement of sinuses in patients acutely sensitive to draughts, improving but not cured by Merc. may be helped by Hep51; scrofulosis44; throat diseases30; inflammation with threatened suppuration to cause absorption13,90 when inspite of Merc. suppuration continues36,90; caries ossicle in inflammatory process95; atonic dyspepsia13; hypostatic pneumonia44; cold16; coryza, nares sore

25/03/2013 10:58 AM

Duration of Action of Remedies - Homeopathy Forums

14 of 20

http://forums.hpathy.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=2804

and ulcerated when discharge becomes thick and yellow, more red, swollen and tender, nasal ages sensitive to inhaled air17; furunculosis95; atrophic rhinitis when Merc. seems indicated but does not relieve93; catarrh16; stomatitis39; gonorrhoea, when suppuration threatens, attended with throbbing in perineum and Merc. having proved ineffective101; scarlatina40; when Merc. ceases to help in rheumatism, quincy, boils and suppurations50], Hydr [Scrofulous ozaena and ulcers in the throat128], Iod [Scarlatina40; jaundice, liver cirrhosed, stool clay colour, tenderness over liver39], Jac-g [Pharyngitis acuta with much dysphagia when Merc. seems indicated but fails24], Kali-bi [Diphtheria and throat affections1], Kali-chl [Scurvy44], Kali-i [Acute nasal catarrh when Merc. has done all it can, or fails, especially in syphilitic subjects48; syphilis, with fistulous openings, thin offensive, corrosive ichorous discharge, or suppuration storm; difficult cough39; epistaxis39; gonorrhoea when a little, thin, gleety discharge remains48; acute rheumatism of children80], Kali-m [Scurvy33], Lach [Hepatitis40; ovarian tumours even when suppuration has taken place33; inflammation of salivary glands and stomatitis when Merc. and other remedies fail36; gums swollen, spongy, easily bleeding and especially if they turn purple48; abdominal inflammation with suppuration or if suppuration ensues and Merc. fails or if gangrene threatens, also, typhlitis16; rheumatism when Merc. fails166], Lyc, Merc-c [Severe stubborn forms of eczema when Merc-v. seems indicated but does not relieve64; dysentery when Merc. fails138], Merc-i-f [Chancroid when Merc. seems indicated but fails24], Mez [Violent pain involving teeth and pain in face with constant chilliness when Merc. fails2; neuralgia, worse at night, involves head, when Merc. fails39; otalgia violent, involves the face and teeth, chilly, after Merc. fails39; chronic inflammation of ear where Merc. seems indicated but fails13; ciliary neuralgia after operation16; diarrhoea when Merc. has been improperly given103], Mur-ac [Typhoid138], Nit-ac [Syphilitic affections of skin, mucous membranes and sense organs when Merc. fails66,101; tertiary syphilis, osteitis, periostitis101; gleet when Merc. has been employed without benefit101; intercurrent remedy when Merc. fails in all stages44; aphthae, stomatitis with ptyalism, swelling of the gums, foetor oris etc. when Merc. is without avail48; throat diseases30], Nux-v [Coryza44], Phos, Pilo [Sweating of rheumatic fever50], Plat [Oophoritis7,20; caries of bones particularly nasal bones and tarsus24], Psor [After acute attack of appendicitis subsides131], Puls [Coryza44; bronchitis6], Rhus-t [Dysentery, very efficacious when diarrhoea only remains138], Sep, Sil134* [In inflammatory processes ... Merc. does not prevent formation of pus but rather helps it and should, therefore, be used when you are convinced of formation of pus, Sil. follows Merc. after Merc. has done its work, it prevents further suppuration and tends to hasten the already long-drawn process of slow healing134], Staph [Constipation with bad taste in the mouth, irregular appetite and pain in the gums, where Merc. does not suffice118], Still [It has been used with success in many cases where Merc, Aur and Thuj. failed to do any good134], Sulph [Dysentery when tenesmus and blood has ceased and mucous still persists16; dysentery when Merc. fails39; dysentery after Merc. has removed the acute symptoms138; helminthiasis, hepatitis40; gonorrhoea when a little thin gleety discharge remains48; also

25/03/2013 10:58 AM

Duration of Action of Remedies - Homeopathy Forums

15 of 20

http://forums.hpathy.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=2804

gonorrhoea when Merc, Cann-s, Canth and Merc-c. do not act promptly and satisfactorily48; skin itching134], Thuj, Tub [Constitutional diseases when Merc-i and also Sulph and Thuj fail139]. Inimical: Acet-ac, Lach8, SIL* [In potentized form Sil. and Merc. are inimical, yet high potencies of Sil. will sometime antidote crude effects of Mercury30,39; Sil. potentized may be used to good effect in ulcers, caries etc. from abuse of crude Merc. when the symptoms call for its istration17]. When a blunder in prescribing has been made and Sil. has been given after Merc. with alarming recrudescence of the bad symptoms. then Hep. comes in and "straightens things out56." N.M. Chouduri has his own unique personal clinical experience of following Sil. after Merc. Antidotes: Acet-ac34, Alum139, Ang, Ant-c31, Arn139, Ant-t, Aran, Arg-met31, Ars [Also rarely useful for intoxicating effects of massive doses111], Asaf [Bone affections, extreme sensitiveness of diseased parts, extreme soreness around eyes12,16; ailments from abuse of Merc. in Syphilis25; chronic effects50], AUR [Suicidal mania157, caries of bones especially patella and nose12,16; melancholy after abuse of Merc39; effects of over dosing with Merc. in treatment of venereal diseases56,95; suppuration of glands after Merc79; rheumatism after mercury166; deep ulcers affecting the bones50 -Kali-i50, Nit-ac50], Aur-m [Over dosing of Merc. in multiple cerebro-spinal cases54; profound melancholia in arteriosclerosis, in leutics, after misuse of Mercury50], BELL, Bry, Calad, C-i, Calc, Calc-f, Camph, Caps [Abuse of Merc12], CARB-V [Pathogenic effects38], Caust [Sometimes12; abuse of Merc. in scabies1,31,56], CHIN [Chronic ptyalism12,16,157; also rarely useful for intoxicating effects of massive doses111], Chion [Hepatic derangements after abuse of Mercury33], Cina, Cinnb [Effects of over medication with Mercury50], Clem, Cob-n, Con [Swellings of lymphatics25], Cupr, Cory-c, Coral, Daph [Pains of Mercury25], DULC [Salivation especially when worse in damp weather16; ptyalism worse by every damp change12; bad effects or abuse of mercury1,33,111; abuse of Merc25], Elec, Ferr [Also rarely useful for intoxicating effect of massive doses111], Fl-ac [Abuse of Mercury25], Guaj [Abuse of Mercury in rheumatism, gout, contractions25,120; also rarely useful for intoxicating effects of massive doses111], HEP [Principle antidote especially for pain in head at night, falling off of the hair, painful nodes on head, inflammed eyes, ptyalism and ulcerated gums, swelling of glands etc. etc33; chemical antidote, the inconvenience produced by small doses of Merc. unhomoeopathically istered71; mental symptoms12; anxiety, distress, suicidal and homicidal mood, bone pains, sore mouth ulcers and gastric symptoms12; itching of upper limb after abuse of Merc39; especially abuse of Mercury16; overdosing with Merc106; mental, bones, gastric and ulcerations157], Hydr, Hyos, IOD [Affections of glands12,16], Iris, Jac-g, Kali-bi, Kali-chl [Spongy gums bleeding easily, aphthous ulcers in mouth, throat and foetor of breath16], KALI-I [[Said to be the best antidote for all the bad effects of Mercury50 though doubtless NIT-AC. is equally valuable50; also intoxicating effects of massive doses111;

25/03/2013 10:58 AM

Duration of Action of Remedies - Homeopathy Forums

16 of 20

http://forums.hpathy.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=2804

syphilis and mercurialism combined; bones, periosteum, glands, ozaena, thin watery discharge, upper lip sore and raw, repeated catarrh after Mercury, every little exposure to damp or wet air - coryza, eyes hot, watery, swollen, neuralgic pains in cheeks, nose obstructed with simultaneous profuse watery scalding coryza, sore throat worse every fresh exposure12; syphilitic iritis after abuse of Merc39; overdosing with Merc106; osseous troubles and hypersensitivity to cold157], Kali-m [Scorbutus fetor12], Kreos, LACH [Occasionally when mercurial poison has been engrafted upon the constitution16], Lyc, Mag-m [Metrorrhagia12], Merc [High potency to antidote bad effects of crude Mercury1], Merc-c [The best antidote of Merc-sol98], Mez [Large doses or too frequent repetition1,50; invalidism36,111; poisoning by Merc36; affections of nervous systems157, neuralgia12,16, in eyes, face, teeth etc. etc2,12; violent pain in teeth and face2], Mur-ac, Nat-m, NIT-AC [Best antidote98; syphilitic ulcers after abuse of mercury, when lower tissues are attacked, as periosteum, the bones and fibrous tissues, particularly if secondary syphilis is complicated by Mercurial poisoning16; abuse of Mercury1; abuse of Merc. after ulceration of palate and throat56; inflammatory swelling of inguinal and axillary gland after abuse of Merc56; also intoxicating effects of massive doses111; troubles grave, cachectic tendency, ulcerations, haemorrhages, lesions bony and mucous membranes157], Nux-m [Inhalation of Merc120], Nux-v [Tremors12,25], Op, Phos, Ph-ac [Caries of vertebra after abuse of Mercury16], PHYT [Bone pains38; mercurial poisoning, stomatitis54], Podo [Bad effects of Mercury1,34, vapours12], Puls [Bad effects of vapours of Mercury13], Ranun, Rat, Rhod [Pains of syphilis after a prolonged course of Merc79], Rhus-g, Rhus-t, Ruta, Sars [Antidotes Merc. and establishes the reaction30; red spots64; rheumatism after Merc39; marasmus after abuse of Merc103], Sel [Itch suppressed by Mercury1, 34; moist itching spots and tingling of skin after local treatment of eruptions especially by Merc145], Sep, Sil [Effects of crude mercury16,30,111], Spig, STAPH [Nutritional disorders by excessive mercurialization157; bad cases50; chronic effects13; system depreciated by mercurial poison16, depressed system, sallow, dark rings round eyes, spongy gums, ulcers on tongue12, and well marked bone pains16; fig warts dry pedunculated, after abuse of Merc30,64; constitutional effects of Merc134; swelling of tonsils after abuse of Merc30], Still [Broken down constitutions with periosteal inflammation and nodes on bone16], Stram, SULPH [Abuse of Merc. in typhoid115], Sul-i [Bad effects of Merc. on mouth30,50], Ter, Thuj [Also intoxicating effects of massive doses111; after long term use of Merc. in strong doses157], Valer, Zinc. All symptoms agreeing Merc. high in potency12. Sulphur bath. Collaterals: Aloe [Acute ulcerative colitis -Merc, Nit-ac, Podo], Ant-c [Ophthalmia worse from glare of fire], Apis [Children have stool as intermingling of blood, mucous and food like tomato sauce], Arg-n, Arist-cl, Ars [Anuria and terminal uraemia -Phos, Plb], Ars-i [Temperature extremes agg. -Ars-i, Calc-f, Calc-s, Calc-sil, Cinnb, Ip, Lyc, Nat-c, Nat-m, Sulph, Sul-ac, Syph], Asaf [Iritis], Aur, Bapt [Stomatitis of nursing mothers], Bar-c, Bar-m [Obstinate scrofulous affections and suppurations of glands], Bell, Brom [Endocarditis or pericarditis with pain from below

25/03/2013 10:58 AM

Duration of Action of Remedies - Homeopathy Forums

17 of 20

http://forums.hpathy.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=2804

upwards], C-i, Calc [Scrofulous diathesis, also Bar-c, Calc-ph, Calc-f, Hep, Merc, Psor, Sil, Sulph, Tub], Calc-f, Canth [Child pulls at penis], Capp [Polyuria, glandular affections, mucous diarrhoea, influenza], Carb-v [Reaction remedy in cachexia syphilitica], Cham [Pain with profuse sweating], Chel [Lower lobe of right lung, stitches through to back -Kali-c], Cinnb [Affections of eyes], Cist [Mononucleosis], Cob-n [Bone pains], Con, Epil [Chronic diarrhoea with tenesmus and mucous discharges; ptyalism, dysphagia; wasting of body and much debility, cholera infantum], Eryth [Pityriasis rubra and syphilis], Euph [Blepharitis and conjunctivitis from cold], Gaert, Guaj, Hench [Gastro-enteritis, nausea, vomiting of bile and frothy mucous, stools watery, profuse, slimy, tenesmus, never get done feeling], Hep [Panarthritis], Iod, Jab [Salivation], Kali-i [Hard chancre; burning in face, running coryza and agg. from heat and warmth of bed], Kali-m, Kreos [Gingivitis of diabetics], Led [Nocturnal emissions stained with blood], Lept [Bilious troubles], Lol [Trembling of hands and legs], Lyc, Lyss [Tendency to kill spouse when asleep], Mag-c [Every change in temperature affects profusely -Bry, Chel, Kali-i, Mang, Phos, Rhod], Mag-f [Focal infection in nose], Mag-m [Lying on right side agg.], Med [Profuse salivation at night on sleeping], Merc-ac [Congestion with stiffness, dryness and heat of parts affected, lack of moisture, throat dry, talking difficult, chancre in urethra], Merc-ar [Syphilis tertiary, especially of bones; syphilis of glands], Merc-k-i [Inveterate colds, acute facial paralysis], Merc-c [Violent inflammatory processes; syphilis with extreme depression; rapid spreading ulcers in diphtheria; Merc: slowly spreading], Merc-d, Merc-o-f [Syphilis in patients with gastro enteritis or if very sensitive to ordinary Merc. preparations], Merc-i-cum-kali-i [A wonderful sinus remedy as well as valuable remedy in certain chronic rheumatic states. Arthritis, neuritis and all painful complaints worse at night and resisting all other remedies], Merc-i-f [Eye diseases and throat symptoms -Merc-i-r], Merc-n [Pustular conjunctivitis and keratitis, gonorrhoea and mucous patches with stitching pains; syphilides], Merc-p [Nervous diseases from syphilis], Merc-pr-r [Suffocative attacks at night on lying down while on the point of falling asleep, gonorrhoea, urethra felt as hard string], Mez [Crown intact, roots of teeth decay -Merc: crown of teeth decay, roots intact; pain in long bones, periosteum, worse at night -Kali-i, Phyt], Nit-ac [Ulcers which are offensive, granulating, bleeding easily, characteristically irregular in outline, tending to dip deeply, agg. by light touch, pain giving sensation as being produced by splincter;Merc: ulcers superficial, painful to touch giving senstion of sharp point stitching into the tissues; when mercurialization is coned with syphilis], Nux-v [Dysentery with tenesmus which ceases after stool, Merc: persistent tenesmus], Op [Answers questions slowly -Lyc, Ph-ac], Phos, Phyt, Plan [Pain in teeth with increased salivation], Plb [Black spots on nails, also Carb-v, Phos], Puls [Ripe cold in nose with greenish yellow discharge, ophthalmia purulent; milk in breasts of non-pregnant women and girls; Merc: of boys], Rhus-t [Pneumonia in alcoholic patients], Ruta, Sep [Cold and heat of room agg. -Carb-ac, Graph, Ip, Merc], Sil, Sulph [Pruritus vulvae worse at night and from of urine], Syph [Hutchinson's teeth], Thuj, Thea [Urge to kill a loved one especially own child - Arg-n, Nux-v, Sulph], Til [Sweat

25/03/2013 10:58 AM

Duration of Action of Remedies - Homeopathy Forums

18 of 20

http://forums.hpathy.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=2804

increases as rheumatic pains increase], Tub [Extreme sensitiveness to atmospheric influences, so sensitive to change of weather, to cold and heat].

Lady Homoeopathic Doctor Computer Programmer & Network

Diplomat Member

Posted: 27 Feb. 05 at 13:43

Thank you very much for the wonderful explanation. Today, he talked to me on telephone. He was sick. The fever was 104 with cough, coryza, URT infection and cold. He is on leave for three days. I suggested him to take a dose of hepar sulph 200. In this season this remedy greatly helps.

ed: 07 Nov. 03 Location: Pakistan Online Status: Offline Posts: 768

Diplomat Homeopath

PHompath

Posted: 27 Feb. 05 at 21:00

Member

Shakeel, I have seen very knowledgable posts under your name. How do you gather all different types of information?

ed: 06 Feb. 05 Location: Pakistan Online Status: Offline Posts: 64

Lady Homoeopathic Doctor Computer Programmer & Network

gavinimurthy Member

Posted: 28 Feb. 05 at 04:06

Who was sick? Dr.Mas??? And you are prescribing for him.!! There is some thing wrong, with my understanding, obviously. Can you clarify?

The Engineer

Murthy

ed: 11 Sept. 04 Location: India Online Status: Offline Posts: 3665

Avoid doing things to others which will make you red when others do it to you. Mahabharat-Hindu Epic

Diplomat Member

Posted: 28 Feb. 05 at 16:59

Yes, he (Dr. MAS) is seriously ill. The fever was 104F. The probable disease is phyrangitis

25/03/2013 10:58 AM

Duration of Action of Remedies - Homeopathy Forums

19 of 20

http://forums.hpathy.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=2804

including URT infection with lot of whitish phlegm. He was feeling cold. He was using

ed: 07 Nov. 03 Location: Pakistan Online Status: Offline Posts: 768

two blankets. He is taking medicine from H/Dr. Nasim Ahmed Sandhu. Who is his closed friend and very good practitioner. Me and Dr. Aamir Shahzad have decided to meet him today. Edited by H Dr Shahkeel

Diplomat Homeopath

Diplomat

Posted: 28 Feb. 05 at 17:15

Member

Ph I am a student. Internet is hobby. I use to search different item from it. I visit many sites whenever I find time.

ed: 07 Nov. 03 Location: Pakistan Online Status: Offline Posts: 768

Diplomat Homeopath

gavinimurthy Member

Posted: 28 Feb. 05 at 18:24

Can't Dr.Mas treat himself? He is a homeopathic practitioner, that too a celebrity in Pakistan. I saw some brilliant prescriptions from him. You claim to be a student, and are you treating Dr.Mas?

The Engineer ed: 11 Sept. 04 Location: India Online Status: Offline Posts: 3665

Is it something like an allopathic doctor, going to another doctor? I am still confused. Murthy

Avoid doing things to others which will make you red when others do it to you. Mahabharat-Hindu Epic

PHompath

Posted: 28 Feb. 05 at 20:57

Member

Gavinimurthy,

ed: 06 Feb. 05 Location: Pakistan Online Status: Offline Posts: 64

When a doctor suffers some illness, his mental capability got disturbs. The best choice is to consult a doctor who can better examine your signs and symptoms. To a patient doctor also, it is difficult to observe sign and diagnosis steps. Observing chest congestion from front and back is also difficult. I think he did right thing in consulting another homeopath. This is same like Barber who runs for another barber for his own hair cutting.

Edited by PHompath

Lady Homoeopathic Doctor Computer Programmer & Network

gavinimurthy Member

Posted: 28 Feb. 05 at 23:39

O.K.

25/03/2013 10:58 AM

Duration of Action of Remedies - Homeopathy Forums

20 of 20

http://forums.hpathy.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=2804

The confusion is cleared. Murthy The Engineer ed: 11 Sept. 04 Location: India Online Status: Offline Posts: 3665

Avoid doing things to others which will make you red when others do it to you. Mahabharat-Hindu Epic

Post Reply Ads by Google

► Tooth Pain Remedies ► Throat Mucus Remedies ► Homeopathy Medicine "The New Bible Cure for Stress: Ancient Truths, Natural Remedies, and the Latest Findings for Your Health Today " $9.09 - Audible.com Get this Audiobook Today! Listen on your iPhone or Android. Forum Jump

Forum Permissions

25/03/2013 10:58 AM